Valley of Elah |
Written by Stephen Langfur |
|
The Bible gives the setting for David's encounter with Goliath in unusual detail:
Socoh and Azekah have been identified, so we might think it easy to work out the geography of this battle. Socoh is a hill containing much pottery from the Israelite period (as well as Roman and Byzantine). A derivative of its name was preserved in a ruin 500 meters east of the hill called Shuweikeh in Arabic. Near the hill's western foot, amid the brambles, diligent searchers can find an old well, whose stonework is reminiscent of Abraham's Well in Beersheba. This is probably "Samson's well at Socoh," mentioned by Jerome (Epistle 108, 14, noted in Keel [pp. 844-845]). Here, according to Judges 15: 14-19, Samson slew a thousand Philistines with the jawbone of an ass. Socoh did not exist long enough to accumulate layers, and it is not a tell. Azekah is. It presides over the Elah Valley, looking west toward Gath and east toward the Judean range, at the point where the valley wiggles and narrows. Because of this strategic position, it was occupied in the third and second millennia BC, as well as in the time of the Philistines and Israelites. Among the letters written on sherds that were found at Lachish, from the time of the Babylonian invasion in 587 BC, one reads: "And [my lord] should know that we are waiting for the signals from Lachish, as we are following all the instructions given by my lord. For we can no [longer] see [the signals from] Azekah." A derivative of Azekah's name was preserved in that of the nearby Arab village Zakariyyah, whose mosque can still be seen today, although it is now an Israeli Jewish town. Given these identifications, then, the geography of the battle should be easy to figure out. Yet there are two possibilities, because the Valley of Elah makes a 90 degree turn from east to south. Possibility 1
When we look at the stretch of the Elah Valley between Socoh and Azekah, everything seems to fit. It's easy to imagine the armies facing each other with the brook between them. The Israelites are close enough to hear Goliath's frightening challenge. The Philistines are stretched between Socoh and Azekah, just as the Bible says. Here is a photo taken from the slope of Socoh, followed by a satellite image:
The Philistines were massed at Socoh, with their camp in the valley between Socoh and Azekah (at Ephes Dammim, meaning "boundary of blood."). The Israelites had taken their stand at the foot of Mount Judah to the east, where the passage to Bethlehem begins. Here, again, are a photograph and a satellite image:
This is the possibility espoused by George Adam Smith (p. 161):
It is the very battlefield for those ancient foes: Israel in one of the gateways to her mountain-land; the Philistines on the low hills they often overran; and between them the valley that divides Judah from the Shephelah. … Socoh is a strong position isolated from the rest of the ridge, and keeps open the line of retreat down the valley. Saul's army was probably not exactly opposite, but a little way up on the slopes of the incoming Wadi el-Jindy [today Nahal ha-Nativ], and so placed that the Philistines, in attacking it, must cross not only the level and the main stream, but one of the two other streams as well, and must also climb the slopes for some distance. Both positions were thus strong, and this perhaps explains the long hesitation of the armies in face of each other…
We return to the first possibility. On closer inspection, there is a strategic point here. The Valley of Elah broadens out to the east and west, but between Azekah and Socoh it narrows into a long bottleneck. Hills mass on either side, blocking any chance of alternative access from Philistine territory to the ridge that climbs to Bethlehem. If Saul could stop the Philistines in the bottleneck, that would secure this access.
Once on top, we can cross to the northern edge for Possibility 1, or to the eastern for Possibility 2. The return descent is very steep, and people should hold hands or form human chains (a bonding experience!). In February, by the way, Socoh's slopes are full of lupines. Then David said to the Philistine, “You come to me with a sword, and with a spear, and with a javelin: but I come to you in the name of Yahweh of Armies, the God of the armies of Israel, whom you have defied. Today, Yahweh will deliver you into my hand. I will strike you, and take your head from off you. I will give the dead bodies of the army of the Philistines this day to the birds of the sky, and to the wild animals of the earth; that all the earth may know that there is a God in Israel, and that all this assembly may know that Yahweh doesn’t save with sword and spear: for the battle is Yahweh’s, and he will give you into our hand.” (1 Samuel 17: 42 - 47)
It is no wonder, then, that the Philistines were filled with panic on seeing Goliath fall. Something uncanny had occurred. They had glimpsed the workings of a Divinity different from any they had known. |